A dry bag above, cold drinks below
RTIC Chillout bag alternatives on Amazon
The Chillout solves a particular problem: towels and dry gear need space, while lunch needs an insulated compartment. These six Amazon-linked alternatives cover different packing needs, from a split beach bag to dedicated soft coolers.
The quick answer
Start with the OdyseaCo Aruba if you want beach gear above a separate cooler compartment. Its mesh upper differs from the Chillout's enclosed dry top, and current Amazon availability needs checking. For a smaller picnic tote, compare the Montero. For cold food and drinks without a large dry compartment, consider the Hydro Flask 20 L cooler or the RTIC options below. None is presented as an exact copy of the original.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Every shopping button in this guide links to an Amazon.com product listing. Listings may be sold by Amazon or third-party sellers. Prices, stock, shipping and variations can change; an identified listing is not a guarantee of an available offer. This is a specification-based comparison, not a hands-on cooling test.
Start with the compartments
What are you replacing?
RTIC's 2-in-1 Chillout Bag combines a 25 L non-insulated upper compartment with a separate insulated base rated for 24 cans. Those figures describe two different spaces. They should not be added together or compared with a cooler's total liter capacity as if they measured the same thing.
Gear and lunch in one bag
A separate upper area keeps towels out of the lunch compartment. For this job, the Aruba is the relevant alternative here, although its mesh construction provides less protection from rain and splashes. Check the actual opening and compartment dimensions against your beach load.
More room for chilled supplies
A dedicated cooler puts its main compartment toward food and drinks. This works when you already have another tote for gear. The Hydro Flask, Montero and three other RTIC models below belong in this group.
Compare the original through its Amazon listing. It is the reference bag, not an additional alternative.
Six Amazon-linked models
Compare the part of the bag you will actually use
| Model | Cold capacity | Separate gear space | Reason to consider it |
|---|---|---|---|
| OdyseaCo Aruba mesh beach bag with cooler | Separate cooler base; can count not established | Yes, mesh gear section | Towels and a smaller lunch together |
| PICNIC TIME / Oniva Montero cooler tote | 20-can stated capacity | Small exterior storage, not a full dry top | Lunch and drinks in a tote |
| Hydro Flask Carry Out soft cooler 20 L | 38 cans without ice | No separate large dry section | Food containers and more cold space |
| RTIC Everyday Insulated Slim Tote | 24 cans or 4 wine bottles | No Chillout-style upper gear compartment | Upright bottles and everyday carry |
| RTIC Backpack Cooler 24 Can | 24-can stated capacity | No comparable large dry top | Keeping both hands free |
| RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler 50 Can | 50-can model designation | No large separate dry compartment | A larger drinks and food load |
Choose by your load
What do you need the bag to carry?
Pick your main requirement
For separated beach gear, compare pick 1. For a small picnic, see pick 2. Pick 5 carries a cooler on your back; picks 3 and 6 offer larger stated drink capacities.
The exact models
Six alternatives, with the compromises made clear
OdyseaCo Aruba mesh beach bag with cooler
Mesh upper bag + insulated lower compartment
The Aruba is the closest layout match in this selection. Its mesh upper bag holds beach gear while a separate insulated section carries food or drinks. That arrangement gives a towel its own space instead of asking you to squeeze it into the cooler. The listed design also has padded handles and exterior pockets for smaller belongings.
Choose it when the purpose of the Chillout appeals to you more than its enclosed upper compartment. Mesh lets you see what you packed and allows air through, but it also exposes contents to the surroundings. Put anything that needs protection in its own pouch.
Before buying: The mesh upper is not waterproof dry storage. A comparable 25 L dry capacity and 24-can cooler capacity have not been established for this exact listing. Check Amazon for an available offer before making this your first choice.
Check availability on Amazon
PICNIC TIME / Oniva Montero cooler tote
20-can stated capacity · water-resistant liner
The Montero is a simpler choice for carrying a picnic. Its main compartment is insulated, with a stated 20-can capacity and a water-resistant interior liner. Exterior zippered storage gives small items their own place. It suits someone who already carries towels in a separate beach bag.
The Amazon listing identifies this as a PICNIC TIME product, while the description uses Oniva, a Picnic Time brand. Those names refer to the same Montero model here. Use the exact linked listing when checking the color and strap arrangement.
Before buying: Twenty cans is a capacity claim, not a promise that 20 drinks plus lunch and ice packs will fit. Its smaller exterior storage does not replace the Chillout's large upper compartment.
Check availability on AmazonHydro Flask Carry Out soft cooler 20 L
20 L cooler · 38 cans without ice in the matched listing
This is the box-shaped 20 L Carry Out soft cooler in Cascade Blue, with a hinged top and removable crossbody strap. It is a different product from the Carryout tote used in the earlier comparison. The matched product record lists 38 cans without ice, so the original tote's 24-can figure would be wrong for this bag.
The wide top is useful when your picnic revolves around food containers: check your largest container against the opening and allow room for cold packs around it. The design concentrates its usable main space on chilled contents rather than an upper gear bag.
Before buying: Check that Amazon still shows the 20 L cooler, not a backpack or another size. Product families can share variation selectors. The can count excludes ice, and there is no large towel compartment.
Check availability on AmazonRTIC Everyday Insulated Slim Tote
24 cans or 4 wine bottles · slim insulated tote
The Slim Tote keeps the tote shape but changes the job. RTIC lists room for 24 cans or four wine bottles, making it worth considering for a picnic where bottle height matters. It is an alternative within RTIC's range, not a competing brand or a duplicate of the Chillout.
A slimmer bag can be easier to place beside other luggage, but the useful test is your own packed load. Lay out the bottles, food and cold packs you plan to bring before choosing it. Bottle capacity is an alternative packing arrangement, not extra room on top of the can count.
Before buying: You give up the Chillout's separate 25 L gear area. Bring another bag for towels and clothes. Check the selected color, dimensions and available seller on Amazon.
Check availability on AmazonRTIC Backpack Cooler 24 Can
24-can cooler backpack · dedicated chilled storage
This RTIC backpack is for carrying the cooler load on your back. The linked product is the 24-can Backpack Cooler, which is distinct from the 2-in-1 Chillout Backpack in the original draft. It makes sense when the walk from the parking lot is the problem you want to solve.
Treat it as a cooler with backpack straps. Towels and a change of clothes still need another home. Keeping the cooling task separate from the gear task may suit a family that already splits supplies between two people.
Before buying: Do not carry over the Chillout Backpack's 16 L dry-top or laptop-sleeve claims to this model. Confirm the selected 24-can variation; RTIC also sells other backpack sizes.
Check availability on AmazonRTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler 50 Can
50-can model · soft-sided cooler
The 50-can Ultra-Tough is the largest named cooler model in this shortlist. Its purpose is carrying more chilled supplies, so it is worth a look when the Chillout's lower compartment is the part you repeatedly outgrow. The Amazon listing describes a waterproof zipper and a puncture- and tear-resistant liner.
A bigger cooler can solve the food-space problem while creating a carrying problem. Count the weight of drinks and ice as part of the decision, and consider how far the loaded bag needs to travel. A shoulder strap does not make a full group picnic weightless.
Before buying: This replaces the cooling job, not the combined gear-and-cooler layout. The 50-can label does not establish how many cans fit alongside your ice and food. Follow the zipper care instructions.
Check availability on AmazonCapacity, not cooling performance
How the stated can counts compare
A larger number does not tell you whether a lunch container fits through the opening. Nor does it say how much room remains for ice. Start with the food containers and cold packs you use, then decide how much drink capacity you need.
Food and gear need different treatment
Pack for the trip, not the headline capacity
Keep perishables at 40°F or below with ice or frozen gel packs, following the FDA's outdoor food guidance. Insulation slows warming; it does not refrigerate a warm lunch. Keep the cooler shut between uses, and use a thermometer to check the temperature.
- Chill food and drinks before packing, then leave enough space for ice packs.
- Contain raw meat and poultry separately so juices cannot reach ready-to-eat food.
- Put towels and sunscreen in another compartment or bag, away from food.
- Keep frequently opened drinks separate from perishable food when practical.
- Clean spills and let the liner dry before storing the bag.
The FDA says perishable food should not sit out for more than two hours, reduced to one hour above 90°F. A maker's cooling-duration claim does not guarantee safe temperatures for your particular trip.
Check the Amazon variation before ordering
Match the model, size and selected style to this guide. A product page can offer a tote, cooler or backpack through the same selectors. Check the seller, delivery date and returns information as well. If the linked item has no offer, do not assume a suggested replacement has the same compartments or capacity.
Before switching bags
Common questions
Which alternative is closest to the Chillout layout?
The OdyseaCo Aruba has a gear section above a separate insulated cooler compartment. Its mesh upper is less enclosed than RTIC's dry top. Check dimensions and Amazon availability before choosing it.
Are all the shopping links Amazon links?
Yes. Every shopping button links to an exact Amazon.com product listing. The linked products can be offered by Amazon or third-party sellers, and an available offer is not guaranteed.
Are these all different brands from RTIC?
No. OdyseaCo, PICNIC TIME / Oniva and Hydro Flask provide the other-brand options. The Slim Tote, Backpack Cooler and Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler are different products within RTIC's range.
Is the Hydro Flask 20 L cooler the same as the Carryout tote?
No. This guide links the box-shaped 20 L Carry Out soft cooler in Cascade Blue, not the newer Carryout tote. The matched cooler record states 38 cans without ice. Check the variation before ordering.
Does the RTIC 24-can backpack have the Chillout Backpack dry top?
No comparable dry top is established for the linked Backpack Cooler. Do not apply the separate Chillout Backpack's 16 L dry-section or laptop-sleeve specifications to it.
Will the listed number of cans fit with ice?
Do not assume so. Ice packs and food containers reduce drink space. Hydro Flask explicitly states its can count without ice, and packing assumptions vary across the other listings.
Is a mesh compartment a waterproof dry bag?
No. A mesh compartment separates gear from food but lets air and water through. Protect electronics and anything that must stay dry in a suitable sealed pouch.
Have these bags been tested side by side?
No. This guide compares published product information. It does not report hands-on testing, measured cooling time or independent leak tests.
Check your load before buying
Our tote size guide can help you compare carrying space. For other shapes and materials, browse the brand alternatives directory. Measure the items you actually pack, especially rigid lunch boxes and upright bottles, before relying on a bag's advertised capacity.
Sources and disclosure
Product links below identify the models used in this comparison. They are affiliate links. Product information comes from public listing information and matched model specifications; live stock and prices were not confirmed. We have not handled or tested these bags. Diagrams explain compartment types and are not representations of exact product appearance.
- OdyseaCo Aruba mesh beach bag with cooler
- PICNIC TIME / Oniva Montero cooler tote
- Hydro Flask Carry Out soft cooler 20 L
- RTIC Everyday Insulated Slim Tote
- RTIC Backpack Cooler 24 Can
- RTIC Ultra-Tough Soft Cooler 50 Can
- FDA: Handling food safely while eating outdoors
Tote Alternatives is independent and is not affiliated with the manufacturers mentioned. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
